Sicily Travel Surprises: From Geeps to “American” Pizza With Hotdogs?

Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...

Sicily isn’t just about ruins, beaches, and pasta—it’s about quirks that leave you scratching your head one minute and laughing the next. This is an island where goats and sheep merge into geeps you’ll pay for dearly if you hit one, where directions come from fruit vendors instead of street names, and where people drag their guest-room air mattresses straight into the sea. It’s equal parts practical, chaotic, and hilarious—and that’s what makes Sicily so unforgettable. From umbrella girls to posteggiatori and even the sweet Minne di Sant’Agata, the quirky traditions Sicily has to offer will surprise every traveler.

Table of Contents

• Sheep, Goats, and… Geeps?
• Directions by People, Not Streets
• Parking, Valets, and Street Hustles
• Driving in a Comedy Routine
• Food That Stares Back
• Beaches and Guest-Room Mattresses
• Living With Fire Underfoot
• Cue the Godfather

Sheep, Goats, and… Geeps?

At first glance, you think you see sheep grazing along the road. Then one turns its head and you realize—no, that’s a geep, the goat-sheep crossbreed unique to Sicily. They wander the countryside like they own it.

Locals warn: if you hit a geep, you don’t just pay for the animal. You pay for every drop of milk it could have produced, every baby it might have birthed, and all the cheese it would have made. And if the farmer doesn’t think you’ve compensated him fairly, rumor has it he might even hold onto your car as payment. The moral? Drive slow, admire the scenery, and give the geeps the right of way.

Directions by People, Not Streets

Asking for directions in Sicily feels like stepping into a riddle. Locals don’t say, “Go straight for two kilometers and turn right.” Instead, it’s, “Turn left at the blood orange vendor.”

One afternoon, we followed that advice—only to find no vendor at all. Instead, a young woman with a bright umbrella stepped into the road, waving as though she’d been waiting for us. She wasn’t selling oranges. We waved her off, pressed the gas, and sped away, laughing nervously. Steven joked, “So… was that a left turn or a right?” From then on, any umbrella we saw on the roadside became part of our inside joke about Sicilian “landmarks.”

Parking, Valets, and Street Hustles

Find a parking spot in Sicily, and someone will find you. Men step forward, offering to “watch” your car for a few euros. They aren’t official valets, but refusing them feels risky. It’s less about service, more about insurance. A couple of coins buys you peace of mind and, sometimes, even a clean windshield when you return.

These men are known as posteggiatori, or “car parkers.” It’s a blatantly illegal profession carried out in public streets and squares, with Palermo being the worst offender in Sicily. Legally, parking in most of these areas is free, but the posteggiatori don’t let that stop them. Sporting money pouches, baseball caps, and even police whistles, they claim sections of road as “their” territory.

For at least one euro—always payable in advance—they’ll “assist” you in parking your car. Some are Sicilian men who take pride in their hustle, while others are African immigrants working in less profitable corners of the city. The Africans are often more affable, while some Sicilians make it clear that if you don’t pay, your vehicle may mysteriously suffer a new dent or scratch.

Posteggiatori are more than a nuisance; they’ve become part of the fabric of daily life, a reminder that quirky traditions in Sicily aren’t always charming—they can be gritty, persistent, and impossible to ignore.

Driving in a Comedy Routine

Driving is a performance art. Stop signs are treated like polite suggestions. Streets narrow until you wonder if you’re on a road or someone’s private driveway. Garbage occasionally sails out of a car window in front of you.

Locals even warn: if someone throws something at your car, don’t stop. It’s a trap. Sicily teaches you to stay alert, laugh at the absurdity, and keep moving.

Food That Stares Back

Food in Sicily will surprise you. Prawns arrive with legs, antennae, and eyes all intact, staring as if they want the last word. Order a pizza, and you might spot one labeled “American pizza” on the menu—piled high with hot dogs and French fries. The funny part? That combination isn’t American at all. You won’t find it on any menu back home. It’s Sicily’s idea of what Americans eat, and it’s as baffling as it is hilarious.

And then there are desserts. Some pastries are shaped like women’s breasts—and they’re not just for shock value. Called Minne di Sant’Agata, these sweets come from Catania and are tied to the story of Saint Agatha, the city’s patron saint. She was martyred in the 3rd century, and as part of her torture, her breasts were cut off. The pastries honor her sacrifice, with small dome shapes, a cherry on top, and a filling of sweet ricotta, candied fruit, or chocolate, all covered in white icing or marzipan.

Ordering them at a bakery can still feel awkward—you rehearse your Italian while the nonna behind the counter doesn’t even blink. For locals, it’s tradition. For visitors, it’s a mix of reverence and giggles.

Pistachios show up everywhere—in pasta, in spreads, in gelato. Sicilians treat them like liquid gold, and you won’t find this kind of devotion anywhere else in Italy. Once you taste them, you’ll understand why.

Beaches and Guest-Room Mattresses

At the beach, you expect towels and lounge chairs. Instead, you see locals floating in the sea on full-sized air mattresses—the same kind you’d drag out for overnight guests back home. They paddle out like it’s the most natural thing in the world, drifting along with pillows propped behind their heads.

I couldn’t stop laughing the first time I saw it. Steven nudged me and whispered, “Do you think they inflated it this morning or just dragged it out of their spare room?” In Sicily, practicality and absurdity share the same space.

Not all beaches are about the people, though. Some are about the scenery. On the southern coast sits Scala dei Turchi, a giant staircase of white stone that rises from the sea. The surface looks polished but grips under your feet, so you can climb without slipping. From the top, the view of the turquoise water is nothing short of spectacular. It’s the kind of place that reminds you Sicily does drama just as well in nature as it does in daily life.

Did You Know Sicily’s African Connection?

Did you know Sicily has been closely tied to Africa for centuries? The island sits just 90 miles from Tunisia, making it one of Europe’s closest neighbors to the African continent. That geography shaped its history. North African civilizations like the Phoenicians, Carthaginians, and later Arabs didn’t just trade here—they ruled, settled, and became part of the island. Many Sicilians today carry ancestry from those people, a reminder that Africa is not just Sicily’s neighbor but part of its bloodline.

The Arab period between the 9th and 11th centuries left behind lasting influences in food, architecture, and language. Citrus groves, pistachios, almonds, and sugar cane all came from that era, transforming Sicily into the fertile landscape you see today.

You can still spot visible reminders of this connection in towns like Catania. In the city’s main square stands the Fontana dell’Elefante, a black lava elephant carrying an Egyptian obelisk on its back. The statue is playful at first glance, but it’s also symbolic—a blend of Sicilian volcanic stone and North African history, standing together at the heart of the city.

Sicily has always been a meeting point, where cultures crossed paths and left their mark. The grit, the flavors, and even the quirks you notice today are part of that long conversation between Europe and Africa.

Living With Fire Underfoot

Etna dominates the horizon like a watchful giant, its slopes scarred with lava and its peak often hidden in clouds of ash and smoke. Locals glance at it the way you or I might glance at the weather forecast—calm, but with respect. Every eruption leaves its mark, carving black rivers of stone that cut through green hillsides and vineyards.

When you ask Sicilians why they live so boldly—why they drive like rules are optional, why they laugh so loudly, why they never seem to hesitate—they point toward the mountain. “We live at the base of a volcano,” one man told us with a shrug. “So we live.”

It’s a philosophy that explains a lot about Sicily. The grit in their voices, the stubborn pride, even the way they throw themselves into food, wine, and celebration. Life is fleeting when the earth beneath your feet rumbles, so why not enjoy every bite of pasta, every song, every fiery sunset?

Cue the Godfather

Sicily doesn’t just play by its own rules—it scores them too. Visit a tourist town– Taormina, Savoca, or Corleone– and you’ll probably hear the theme from The Godfather drifting through the streets, as if it’s the island’s unofficial anthem. It’s kitschy and theatrical, but somehow it fits. After all, when you live under a volcano, you develop a taste for drama. And in Sicily, the drama is always real—sometimes gritty, sometimes funny, and always worth the story you’ll tell later.

Like it. Pin it.

 

 

 

I love sharing my travel stories, lessons from life abroad, and tips for curious travelers. If my work has inspired you or made you smile, please buy me a coffee.

My articles are available as mobile apps for offline reading and GPS-assisted directions. Download my articles on GPSMyCity. This post contains sponsored and/or affiliate links. If you click these links, I may earn a small commission. Your support helps me keep the blog running—at no cost to you.